Ikibazo gihuza ibibazo · Hagati Urwego

Kubaza AI kunegura Ikibazo cyawe

Saba kunegura byihariye, bifitanye isano nibimenyetso mugihe ugenzura ibitekerezo bya AI kurwanya rubrics, inkomoko, nubucamanza bwabantu mbere yo gukora ubugororangingo.

Inzira zijyanye no kuyoboraKubaza AI kunegura akazi kawe
Ikibazo 1 Bya 8

What should a critique prompt include?

Reba buri kibazo8 ibibazo

Ibisubizo nibisobanuro bigaragara mugihe ufata ikibazo.

  1. What should a critique prompt include?
    • Only “be honest”
    • A request to rewrite without review
    • The work’s purpose, audience, and criteria for useful feedback
    • The model’s favorite writing style
  2. How can a reviewer make criticism more actionable?
    • Ask only for a score out of ten
    • Request generic praise
    • Hide the draft’s intended audience
    • Ask for prioritized issues tied to specific passages and reasons
  3. Does asking for a “skeptical reviewer” guarantee an accurate critique?
    • Yes, for every model
    • No; it requests a stance but does not guarantee correctness or completeness
    • Yes, if the model lists five flaws
    • No, because models cannot review text
  4. What does the cited sycophancy research suggest?
    • Some assistant models may favor responses aligning with user beliefs in tested settings
    • Every model always agrees with every user
    • Critique prompts always fail
    • Humans never prefer agreeable responses
  5. Why ask the model to cite passages in its critique?
    • It proves the critique is correct
    • It eliminates factual errors
    • It helps the author verify what part of the draft the comment concerns
    • It guarantees originality
  6. Why separate diagnosis from rewriting?
    • It guarantees no bias
    • The author can evaluate whether the identified issues are valid before accepting edits
    • It prevents the model from reading the draft
    • It makes style preferences objective
  7. Are two model critiques independent ground truth?
    • Yes, if they use different wording
    • Yes, if both assign the same score
    • No, because only one critique can be useful
    • No; multiple model opinions can share errors and need external checks
  8. What should happen before using AI critique on consequential work?
    • Verify claims against a rubric, sources, experts, or intended readers
    • Publish every suggestion immediately
    • Treat the model as the sole authority
    • Ignore confidentiality concerns