Ikibazo gihuza ibibazo · Hagati Urwego
Kubogama kumoko mubibazo byubuzima Algorithms Ikibazo
Tests the study’s cost proxy, observed disparity, counterfactual allocation result and limits on generalizing one healthcare algorithm study.
Ikibazo 1 Bya 8
Ni iki ubushakashatsi bwakozwe ku baturage-ubuzima bwa algorithm bwahanuye nk'intumwa yo gukenera ubuzima?
Reba buri kibazo8 ibibazo
Ibisubizo nibisobanuro bigaragara mugihe ufata ikibazo.
- Ni iki ubushakashatsi bwakozwe ku baturage-ubuzima bwa algorithm bwahanuye nk'intumwa yo gukenera ubuzima?
- A patient’s preferred clinic
- The number of available physicians
- Race itself
- Future healthcare costs
- Ku manota amwe, abashakashatsi babonye iki ku barwayi b'Abirabura?
- They used fewer medications by design
- They were considerably sicker than White patients
- They had lower disease burden in every measure
- They were excluded from the algorithm
- Ni ukubera iki guhanura ibiciro byasuzuguye ubuzima bw'abarwayi b'abirabura bakeneye ubushakashatsi?
- The model used only age
- The system directly prohibited Black patients from receiving care
- Historical differences in access meant Black patients generated lower costs at similar illness levels
- Costs are never related to health
- Byagenze bite ku mugabane w'abarwayi b'Abirabura bagaragaye kugira ngo bongere ubufasha igihe intego y'ubushakashatsi yahinduwe?
- It increased from 17.7% to 46.5%
- The study did not report a comparison
- It fell from 46.5% to 17.7%
- It stayed exactly the same
- Ni ubuhe butumwa bw'ingenzi budahuye mu bushakashatsi?
- A skin-tone scale was used as a diagnosis
- The algorithm predicted race rather than costs
- Healthcare spending was used instead of a direct measure of illness need
- The model used only clinician notes
- Does the 2019 study prove that every healthcare algorithm is racially biased?
- Yes, every model uses cost
- Yes, because it was published in Science
- No, because the result was only theoretical
- No; it studied a particular algorithm, target and population
- Why can a model be accurate on its chosen target yet still fail to allocate care fairly?
- The target may predict spending well but poorly represent clinical need
- Clinical need is the same as spending by definition
- Accuracy always guarantees equal access
- A risk score cannot affect care
- What should a health system examine when auditing a similar support-allocation model?
- Whether the model contains a race field
- Whether the target reflects clinical need and how outcomes differ across groups
- Only overall model accuracy
- Ibara ry'aho umukoresha akorera gusa