Il prossimoProssima guida
Etica del CPA e dati del cliente quando si utilizza l'intelligenza artificiale
Società
GUIDA della Società
Entering client information into a generative AI tool does not automatically waive attorney-client privilege, but it can put confidentiality at risk when the tool's terms let the provider train on, retain or review inputs.
Ascolta questa guidaNarrato dall'IA · ~3 min
The safer position is using tools under enterprise terms that bar training, limit retention and restrict access, because both the ethical duty of confidentiality and a court's view of waiver depend on whether confidentiality was reasonably protected.
Three protections are often blurred together. Attorney-client privilege is an evidentiary rule shielding confidential communications between lawyer and client made to obtain or give legal advice. Work product protects materials prepared in anticipation of litigation. The ethical duty of confidentiality under Rule 1.6 is broader, covering all information relating to the representation, and requires reasonable efforts to prevent unauthorized disclosure. Privilege is generally waived by voluntary disclosure to a third party outside the privileged relationship. Courts have long accepted, however, that lawyers can use service providers such as email hosts, cloud storage and eDiscovery vendors without waiver when confidentiality is reasonably maintained. AI tools are likely to be analyzed similarly, which makes the vendor's terms central. Case law applying waiver doctrine specifically to AI prompts is still thin, so lawyers should not assume a favorable outcome. Risk rises when terms let the provider use inputs to train models, keep them indefinitely, or allow human reviewers to read them, because each undercuts a claim that the communication stayed confidential. Consumer versions of popular chatbots have generally allowed training on conversations by default unless users opt out, while business and API offerings typically do not. Litigation can also affect retention: in 2025, the court in The New York Times's copyright suit against OpenAI ordered the company, for a period, to preserve user chat logs, including ones users had deleted. Work product is harder to waive; disclosure generally waives it only if it substantially increases the chance that an adversary obtains the material. Clients raise a separate issue. When they discuss their legal problems with a chatbot before or instead of talking to counsel, those conversations are not communications with a lawyer and may be discoverable. A common misconception is that turning off chat history makes a consumer tool safe. It may limit training use, but providers often still retain data for a period for abuse monitoring.
A lawyer pastes a client's email about an internal investigation into a free consumer chatbot with default settings that allow training; even if privilege survives, the lawyer may have fallen short of the duty under Rule 1.6 to take reasonable measures to protect client information.
A firm licenses an AI tool under an enterprise agreement that specifies no training on customer data, a defined retention period, encryption and no vendor access without permission, and records that review in its vendor file.
A client works through the facts of a dispute with a consumer chatbot before calling a lawyer; those chats are communications with a third-party service, not with counsel, and may be discoverable.
Before running a sensitive matter through an AI tool, a lawyer removes client names and identifying details, reducing what would be exposed if the data were ever accessed.
Courts have only begun addressing how privilege and work product apply to AI prompts and outputs, and early decisions may differ by jurisdiction and facts. Commentators and some policymakers have discussed whether conversations with AI should receive special protection, but no such privilege currently exists. Meanwhile, vendors increasingly offer legal-industry terms, private deployments and zero-retention options, which make confidentiality easier to defend. Lawyers should expect more discovery requests aimed at AI chat logs, both their own and their clients', and more firms advising clients directly not to discuss their matters with consumer chatbots.
Newsletter gratuita
Tre storie verificate sull'IA ogni mattina nei giorni feriali, scritte in un inglese semplice. Gratuito per sempre, senza pubblicità.
Un'email ogni giorno feriale. Disiscriviti con un clic. Non vendiamo né condividiamo mai il tuo indirizzo.
Mettiti alla prova
Feedback immediato su ogni risposta e un certificato condivisibile con un ID verificabile una volta superato un corso.
Sostieni l'istruzione gratuita sull'IA. AI Understanding è un'organizzazione non profit 501(c)(3) — nessun annuncio, nessun paywall, mai. Fai una donazione
Entering client information into a generative AI tool does not automatically waive attorney-client privilege, but it can put confidentiality at risk when the tool's terms let the provider train on, retain or review inputs. The safer position is using tools under enterprise terms that bar training, limit retention and restrict access, because both the ethical duty of confidentiality and a court's view of waiver depend on whether confidentiality was reasonably protected.
La regola 1.6 sulla riservatezza è più ampia del privilegio, che copre le comunicazioni riservate per consulenza legale e prodotti di lavoro, che coprono i materiali del contenzioso.
I tribunali hanno da tempo accettato che l’utilizzo di tali fornitori non comporta una rinuncia ai privilegi se la riservatezza è ragionevolmente protetta, ed è probabile che gli strumenti di intelligenza artificiale vengano analizzati in modo simile.
Ciascuno di questi sminuisce l’affermazione secondo cui la comunicazione sarebbe rimasta riservata. Le altre opzioni sono misure di protezione.
L'ordine di conservazione ha dimostrato che il contenzioso può prevalere sulle normali pratiche di cancellazione di un fornitore, il che è importante per qualsiasi cosa inserita in una chat.
È più difficile rinunciare al prodotto del lavoro che al privilegio; il test consueto chiede se la divulgazione abbia reso sostanzialmente più probabile che un avversario ottenga il materiale.
Continua a imparare
Altre guide selezionate per questo argomento
Il prossimoProssima guida
Etica del CPA e dati del cliente quando si utilizza l'intelligenza artificiale
Società