Ubuyobozi bwa tekiniki

Ibipimo bya AI Uburinganire: Uburinganire bwa Demokarasi Kuringaniza

Ibipimo byuburinganire bwamatsinda bipima niba ibyemezo byikitegererezo cyangwa amakosa atandukanye mumatsinda yabaturage.

Umva iki gitaboAI-byavuzwe · ~3 min

Kuriyi page4 min soma
  1. Incamake
  2. Kwibira cyane
  3. Gushyira mu bikorwa Isi
  4. Ejo hazaza h'uburinganire bwa AI: Uburinganire bwa Demokarasi Kuringaniza
  5. Kubishyira mubikorwa
  6. Komeza Ubushakashatsi
  7. Ibibazo bikunze kubazwa

Incamake

Uburinganire bwabaturage bugereranya ibipimo byatoranijwe, amahirwe angana agereranya ibipimo byiza byukuri, ibingana bingana kugereranya ibipimo byiza nukuri nibinyoma, naho uburinganire bwateganijwe bugereranya neza. Ibi bisobanuro bifite akamaro kuko birashobora kuvuguruzanya mu mibare, guhitamo rero ni urubanza rwagaciro kubijyanye nubwoko bwakarengane bufite akamaro cyane murubanza runaka.

Kwibira cyane

Fata icyitegererezo cy'inguzanyo n'amatsinda abiri, A na B, 100 basaba buri umwe. Muri A, 50 bari kwishyura; muri B, 20. Icyitegererezo cyemeza 40 muri A (35 bari kwishyura, 5 batabishaka) na 20 muri B (14 bari kwishyura, 6 batabishaka). Uburinganire bwa demokarasi bugereranya ibipimo byatoranijwe: 40% na 20%. Ikigereranyo cya 0.5 kiri munsi yine ya gatanu ya gatanu (0.8) uhereye kumurongo ngenderwaho wakazi muri Amerika, bityo birananirana. Amahirwe angana agereranya ibipimo nyabyo (TPR), umugabane wabantu babishoboye bemejwe: 35/50 = 0.70 na 14/20 = 0.70. Biranyuzwe. Impuzandengo zingana (Hardt, Igiciro na Srebro, 2016) nazo zisaba ibiciro byiza bingana (FPR): 5/50 = 0.10 na 6/80 = 0.075. Funga, ariko ntibingana. Kuringaniza ibigereranyo bigereranya neza, cyangwa agaciro keza ko guhanura (PPV): 35/40 = 0.875 na 14/20 = 0.70. Birananirana. Iyo ibipimo fatizo bitandukanye, nkuko hano, ibyiciro bidatunganye mubisanzwe ntibishobora guhaza ibisobanuro byinshi icyarimwe. Chouldechova (2017) na Kleinberg, Mullainathan na Raghavan (2016) bagaragaje verisiyo yibi: hamwe n’ibipimo fatizo bingana, uburinganire bwateganijwe cyangwa kalibibasi ntibishobora kugumana ibipimo bibi bitari byiza kandi bibi, usibye mu manza zangirika nko guhanura neza. Impaka za COMPAS nizo rwose amakimbirane. Guhitamo ibipimo biterwa n'imiterere. Uburinganire bwa demokarasi bukwiranye nigihe ibirango ubwabyo bishobora kubogama cyangwa aho intego iringaniye. Amahirwe angana akwiranye nigihe kubura umuntu wujuje ibyangombwa aribyo byangiza. Kuringaniza ibingana byongera impungenge kubirego byibinyoma. Guteganya uburinganire cyangwa kalibrasi yibibazo mugihe abafata ibyemezo basomye amanota nkibishoboka. Igitekerezo gikocamye ni uko gukuraho ikiranga kirinzwe bituma icyitegererezo cyiza. Porokireri zifitanye isano nka kode ya zip irashobora gutwara amakuru amwe.

Gushyira mu bikorwa Isi

Mugukoresha itanga iterambere 40% byabasabye itsinda rimwe na 20% byabandi. Ikigereranyo cya 0.5 kiri munsi ya bine-bitanu byateganijwe gukoreshwa mu isesengura rishingiye ku ivangura ry’akazi muri Amerika, ibyo bikaba bigaragaza impungenge z’abaturage.

Uburyo bwo gusuzuma ubuvuzi bufata 70% byimanza zukuri mumatsinda yombi. Ihaza amahirwe angana, nubwo amatsinda yo guhitamo atandukanye.

Isesengura rya ProPublica ryo mu 2016 ryerekeye igikoresho cyo gusubiramo COMPAS cyasanze abaregwa birabura bafite igipimo cyiza cyo kubeshya. Umucuruzi yashubije ko amanota yayo afite agaciro kamwe ko guhanura mumatsinda. Amakimbirane yerekanaga ibipimo bibiri byuburinganire mu makimbirane ataziguye.

Umuhanga mu bumenyi akoresha MetricFrame ya Fairlearn kugirango agabanye ukuri, igipimo cyo gutoranya nigipimo cyiza cyibeshya kumatsinda. Hanyuma akoresha ThresholdOptimizer kugirango ashyireho itsinda ryihariye ryuzuza ibintu bingana.

Ejo hazaza h'uburinganire bwa AI: Uburinganire bwa Demokarasi Kuringaniza

Ibipimo by'itsinda bigenda byandikwa mubigenzuzi no kugenzura. Amategeko y’Umujyi wa New York yerekeye ibikoresho byifashishwa mu gufata ibyemezo, urugero, bisaba ubugenzuzi bubogamye bwerekana ibipimo by’ingaruka. Ubushakashatsi burakomeje kuburinganire bwa buri muntu, kurenganura kubitera, no kurenganura kubintu bitanga umusaruro, aho ibisubizo byanditse aho kuba yego-cyangwa-oya ibyemezo kandi ibipimo bisanzwe ntibikurikizwa muburyo butaziguye. Ibisubizo bidashoboka ni imibare kandi ntabwo bizashira. Iterambere ry'ejo hazaza birashoboka cyane ko biva mubirango byiza, inyandiko nziza zerekana ibicuruzwa byatoranijwe n'impamvu yabyo, hamwe nabaterankunga batanga kuruta kubipimo rusange.

Kubishyira mubikorwa

Impamvu ari ngombwa

  • Igiciro na bije. Ibyemezo byubwubatsi bitwara imikorere nigiciro cyimikorere kumyaka.
  • Ibyemezo bisobanutse. Ubuhanga bwa tekinike bufasha amakipe guhitamo umurongo ukwiye, ntabwo ari shyashya gusa.
  • Kugenzura ubuziranenge. Guhitamo neza bya injeniyeri bigabanya ibintu byizewe mubikorwa.

Witondere

  • Gutezimbere igipimo kimwe gishobora guhisha intege nke za sisitemu.
  • Ibikorwa Remezo no kubungabunga akenshi usanga bidahabwa agaciro.
  • Icyuho cyumutekano no kwitegereza birashobora kwiyongera uko sisitemu igenda igorana.

Intambwe ikurikira

  1. Sobanura ubukererwe, ubuziranenge, nigiciro cyibiciro mbere yo kubishyira mubikorwa.
  2. Ibipimo byerekana umutwaro ufatika hamwe namakuru yimiterere.
  3. Gukurikirana ibikoresho kubikosa, drift, ningaruka zabakoresha.
  4. Tegura inzira yo gusubiza ibyabaye mbere yo gupima.

Komeza Ubushakashatsi

Ibaruwa y'amakuru y'ubuntu

Ibuka amakuru ya buri munsi ya AI

Inkuru eshatu zizewe za AI buri gitondo cy'iminsi y'akazi, zanditse mu rurimi rworoshye. Ubuntu iteka ryose, nta kwamamaza.

Imeri imwe buri munsi y'akazi. Kwiyimura mu buryo bumwe. Ntitwigera tugurisha cyangwa ngo dusangire aderesi yawe.

Isuzume

Fata ibipimo bya AI Uburinganire: Uburinganire bwa Demokarasi Kuringaniza Ikibazo

Ibisubizo ako kanya kuri buri kibazo, n'icyemezo gishobora gusangirwa gifite ID yagenzurwa umaze gutsinda isomo.

Tangira ikibazo

Fasha uburezi bwa AI bw'ubuntu. AI Understanding ni umuryango utegamiye kuri leta wa 501(c)(3) — nta kwamamaza, nta kwishyura, iteka ryose. Tanga impano

Ibibazo bikunze kubazwa

Uburinganire bwa AI ni ubuhe: Uburinganire bwa Demokarasi Kuburinganire Buringaniye?

Ibipimo byuburinganire bwamatsinda bipima niba ibyemezo byikitegererezo cyangwa amakosa atandukanye mumatsinda yabaturage. Uburinganire bwabaturage bugereranya ibipimo byatoranijwe, amahirwe angana agereranya ibipimo byiza byukuri, ibingana bingana kugereranya ibipimo byiza nukuri nibinyoma, naho uburinganire bwateganijwe bugereranya neza. Ibi bisobanuro bifite akamaro kuko birashobora kuvuguruzanya mu mibare, guhitamo rero ni urubanza rwagaciro kubijyanye nubwoko bwakarengane bufite akamaro cyane murubanza runaka.

Mu ngero z'inguzanyo ziyobora, itsinda A rifite igipimo cyo gutoranya 40% naho itsinda B rifite igipimo cya 20%. Nibihe bipimo bitubahiriza?

Uburinganire bwa demokarasi bugereranya ibipimo byo guhitamo. Ikigereranyo cya 0.5 kirananirana kandi kigwa munsi yine ya gatanu.

Amahirwe angana arasaba ingano ingana gute mumatsinda?

Amahirwe angana arasaba ko abantu babishoboye bemerewe kurwego rumwe, nicyo gipimo cyiza.

Niki kuringaniza ibingana byongeraho amahirwe angana?

Kuringaniza ibingana bisaba ibipimo nyabyo byukuri kandi bingana ibipimo byiza byibinyoma mumatsinda.

Kurugero, itsinda B ryikigereranyo cyibinyoma ni 6 kuri 80. Kuki ari 80?

FPR ingana ibyiza byibinyoma bigabanijwe nibibi byose bifatika. Itsinda B rifite abasaba 100 naho 20 bari kwishyura, hasigara 80 bibi.

Niki kidashoboka ibisubizo biva kuri Chouldechova na Kleinberg nabandi. vuga?

Hamwe nibipimo fatizo bingana, ibi bipimo bivuguruzanya usibye mubibazo byangirika nkuwahanuye neza. Impaka za COMPAS zerekanye aya makimbirane mubikorwa.