HejuruUbuyobozi bukurikira
Michigan ya MiDAS Ubushomeri Algorithm Scandal
Sosiyete
Ubuyobozi
Michigan’s MiDAS unemployment system was introduced in 2013 and, during 2013–2015, automatically adjudicated many fraud allegations without human review.
Umva iki gitaboAI-byavuzwe · ~3 min
Isuzuma rya Leta ryerekanye ko hejuru ya 90% by'ibyo byemezo bya mudasobwa byonyine byari bibi; abasaba kwishyurwa bahuye nibisabwa byo kwishyura, ibihano nibikorwa byo gukusanya. Nyuma ibyemezo byurukiko no gukemura byakemuwe muburyo bukwiye nuburyo bukemurwa, ntabwo ari inenge ya software gusa.
Michigan’s Unemployment Insurance Agency launched MiDAS, the Michigan Integrated Data Automated System, in 2013 as a claims-processing and fraud-detection system. In the 2013–2015 period, the system used data matching and claimant responses to generate fraud allegations, and many findings were made through automated processes without an employee reviewing each file first. Claimants could be required to repay benefits, interest and substantial penalties; the agency could intercept tax refunds or garnish wages. A fraud decision therefore had consequences well beyond a software score. A recurring issue was the difference between time periods in employer wage reports and claimant benefit certifications. Employers reported wages quarterly; claimants certified more frequently. The Auditor General described the delayed matching process, and the state later reviewed computer-only determinations. The settlement notice in Bauserman states that the Auditor General found allegations based on auto-adjudication wrong more than 90% of the time. That figure applies to the reviewed computer-only fraud findings, not every MiDAS decision, every type of unemployment overpayment or all later state cases. Other sources cite 93% based on a particular sample; use the denominator and review period when quoting it. Claimants alleged that notices did not give meaningful reasons and that people who failed to access or answer online questionnaires could be found liable without a fair opportunity to respond. In Bauserman v. UIA, Michigan’s Supreme Court in 2022 held that plaintiffs had alleged a cognizable state constitutional due-process claim for which damages could be sought, and remanded the case. It did not rule that every MiDAS determination was unlawful. A civil-rights class settlement was later approved for eligible claimants. MiDAS was not simply “a buggy program.” The failure combined automation, poor matching and notice, performance incentives, weak human review, collection before an effective hearing and inadequate process design. Safer systems distinguish inconsistency from intent, explain the evidence, allow accessible correction and appeal, and pause collection while a timely dispute is reviewed.
Usaba indishyi yakiriye inyandiko y'uburiganya agasaba ibimenyetso, kubara no gusuzuma abantu mbere yuko icyegeranyo gitangira.
Umugenzuzi w'imari agereranya raporo y'imishahara y'abakoresha buri gihembwe hamwe na nyirubwite ibyemezo byombi kandi akanagenzura igihe cyagenwe mbere yo kwerekana uburiganya butandukanye.
Itsinda ryibicuruzwa bitandukanya ibimenyetso byishyuwe birenze kubushake, ninzira zahatanwe cyangwa ibibazo byinshi cyane kubisubiramo bahuguwe.
Umunyamakuru atandukanya ibyemezo byuburiganya byakozwe na 2013–2015 na sisitemu yinyungu za Michigan hamwe nuburyo bwo gukemura.
MiDAS yemewe n'amategeko ikubiyemo isuzuma rya leta, impinduka za politiki no gukemura ibyiciro, ariko buri muntu wagize ingaruka ku kwemererwa no gutura bitewe nigihe n'ibipimo. Icyemezo cya Bauserman cyo mu 2022 cy’urukiko rwikirenga rwa Michigan kireba ko habaho ikirego cy’indishyi ziteganijwe mu cyiciro gikurikiraho mbere yacyo. Ntugasobanure nk'urubanza rudafite ishingiro ko ibyemezo by'ibigo byose binyuranyije n'Itegeko Nshinga. Gahunda zinyungu za leta zigomba gukoresha sitati iriho, kumenyeshwa kugerwaho, ibimenyetso byihariye nibisubirwamo bifite ireme. Nyuma, automatisation igomba gusubirwamo ukurikije amahame amwe.
Ibaruwa y'amakuru y'ubuntu
Inkuru eshatu zizewe za AI buri gitondo cy'iminsi y'akazi, zanditse mu rurimi rworoshye. Ubuntu iteka ryose, nta kwamamaza.
Imeri imwe buri munsi y'akazi. Kwiyimura mu buryo bumwe. Ntitwigera tugurisha cyangwa ngo dusangire aderesi yawe.
Isuzume
Ibisubizo ako kanya kuri buri kibazo, n'icyemezo gishobora gusangirwa gifite ID yagenzurwa umaze gutsinda isomo.
Fasha uburezi bwa AI bw'ubuntu. AI Understanding ni umuryango utegamiye kuri leta wa 501(c)(3) — nta kwamamaza, nta kwishyura, iteka ryose. Tanga impano
Gahunda y’ubushomeri ya MiDAS ya Michigan yatangijwe mu 2013 kandi, muri 2013–2015, ihita icira imanza ibirego byinshi by’uburiganya nta muntu wasuzumye. Isuzuma rya Leta ryerekanye ko hejuru ya 90% by'ibyo byemezo bya mudasobwa byonyine byari bibi; abasaba kwishyurwa bahuye nibisabwa byo kwishyura, ibihano nibikorwa byo gukusanya. Nyuma ibyemezo byurukiko no gukemura byakemuwe muburyo bukwiye nuburyo bukemurwa, ntabwo ari inenge ya software gusa.
Inyandiko za leta n’urukiko zisobanura ishyirwa mu bikorwa muri 2013.
Imenyekanisha rya Leta ryerekeye gukemura ibibazo rivuga ko ubwo buryo bwaciwe n’ubushakashatsi bwakozwe mu buriganya mu gihe cya 2013–2015, mu gihe abaregera indishyi bavuga ko bakatiwe ndetse n’ikusanyamakuru.
Amatangazo yo gukemura ibibazo by'umushinjacyaha mukuru wa Michigan avuga ko Umugenzuzi mukuru w'imari ya Leta yasanze ibirenga 90% by'ibirego bishingiye ku guca imanza atari byo.
Umugenzuzi Mukuru w'Imari ya Leta asobanura raporo y’imishahara y’abakoresha buri gihembwe ihuye nyuma n’impamyabumenyi zisaba kenshi, bigatera ingaruka nigihe cyo guhuza ibihe.
Urukiko rw'Ikirenga rwa Michigan yavuze mu ncamake ibivugwa ko isuzuma rijyanye na MiDAS ryatumye habaho gukusanya nta nteguza ifatika cyangwa amahirwe yo kumva.
Komeza wige
Abandi bayobozi batoranijwe kuriyi ngingo
HejuruUbuyobozi bukurikira
Michigan ya MiDAS Ubushomeri Algorithm Scandal
Sosiyete