Ku laabo Warka
GanacsigaAI Understanding warbixin kooban

Forbes ayaa sheegaysa ChatGPT waxay soo bandhigtay sida khabiir 3M u dhisay ra'yi masuuliyadeed

Forbes ayaa ku warameysa in khabiir 3M ah uu u adeegsaday ChatGPT si uu u diyaariyo ra'yi doonaya in uu tuso shirkadu in aysan eber khalad ku lahayn qarax ka dhacay Houston. Diiwaanka degdega ah wuxuu noqday caddaynta tijaabada, taasoo muujinaysa khataraha ku xeeran eexda, xaqiijinta, sirta iyo helitaanka.

6 min readRead the original reporting
Source-provided image accompanying Forbes reports ChatGPT prompts exposed how a 3M expert built a liability opinion
Warbixin loo aaneeyayIsha la duubay
Daabacaha
forbes.com
Xidhiidhka isha
forbes.comhttps://www.forbes.com/sites/larsdaniel/2026/08/26/expert-witness-asked-chatgpt-to-show-0-fault-the-wrong-way-for-experts-to-use-ai/
Nooca isha
Ka tebinta warside - ma aha dukumeenti xisbiga koowaad.

Wixii aan si madaxbanaan u xaqiijin karin: Sheegashadan waxaa loo aaneynayaa meesha la magacaabay. Ma aanan xaqiijinin ka dhanka ah dukumeenti xisbiga koowaad. (forbes.com)

Dulucda sheekadaKu fahan tan 60 ilbiriqsi gudahood

Halkan ka bilow

Qodobbada muhiimka ah

AI abuurta
Nidaamyada AI ee soo saara waxyaabo cusub sida qoraal, sawirro, maqal, muuqaal, ama kood.
degdeg
Tilmaamaha wax gelinta iyo macnaha guud ee la siiyay qaab-abuureed.
Eex
Nidaam khalad ah oo joogto ah ama caddaalad darro xagga xogta ama habdhaqanka moodeelka.
Is tijaabiKediska Anshaxa AI

Maxaa dhacay

Forbes waxa ay sheegtay in Injineer Josh Autenrieth uu isticmaalay ChatGPT isaga oo diyaarinaya ra'yi khabiir 3M dacwad ku saabsan qarax ka dhacay Houston 2020. Sida laga soo xigtay Forbes, dacwoodayaashu waxay heleen 365 bog oo soojeedin ah iyo jawaabo moodeel ah, oo ay ku jiraan codsiyo muujinaya in 3M uu 0% mas'uul ka ahaa. Xeerbeegtida Degmada Harris ayaa markii dambe helay Watson Shillinta 70% mas'uul ah iyo 3M 30% ka mas'uul ah, oo ku abaalmariyay $61.5 milyan 24 degane iyo milkiilayaal ganacsi. Forbes ayaa sheegtay in 3M aysan ku raacsanayn xukunka oo ay qorsheynayaan inay racfaan ka qaataan. Faahfaahintan si madax banaan loogama xaqiijin xogtan.

Forbes waxa ay sheegtay in dacwadda hoose ay daba socotay qarax ka dhacay Watson Grinding and Manufacturing oo ku taal Houston Jan. 24, 2020. Warbixintu waxa ay sheegtay in gaaska propylene uu ka soo caariyay tuubo caag ah oo duugowday, is urursatay oo qarxay, halkaas oo ay ku dhinteen laba qof oo shaqaale ah iyo mid ka mid ah dadka deegaanka, isla markaana uu burburiyay boqolaal guri. Forbes waxay soo xiganaysaa Guddiga Badbaadada Kiimikada Maraykanka iyo Guddiga Baadhitaanka Khatarta warbixintii u dambaysay ee ay ku ogaadeen in tuubadadu ay hoos u dhacday oo ay si liidata u naafaysay, gacanta lagu xidho valve aan la xidhin, iyo gaaska-ogaanshaha, qaylo-dhaanta, qiiqa-fan-fan-bilawga iyo nidaamka gaaska- xidhiddu ma shaqaynayn. Dadka deegaanka, qoysaska iyo ganacsiyada ayaa dacweeyay Watson Grinding iyo 3M, iyaga oo ku eedeeyay in 3M aysan si sax ah ugu adeegin nidaamka ogaanshaha gaaska.

Forbes ayaa sheegaysa in 3M ay shaqaaleysiisay Josh Autenrieth, oo ah injineerka KnightHawk Engineering, si uu u bixiyo ra'yi khabiir oo ku saabsan in shaqada 3M ay la kulantay heerka daryeelka. Isagoo tixraacaya 404 Media's warbixintii hore, Forbes ayaa sheegaysa in Autenrieth uu soo galiyay qoraalkiisa iyo boqollaal faylal kiis ChatGPT wuxuuna u sheegay nidaamka uu u baahan yahay si uu u muujiyo in 3M uu la kulmay heerka daryeelka. Dareenada danbe ayaa waydiistay ChatGPT inuu abuuro warbixin khabiir ah oo difaacaya 3M, dib u celi khabiirkii ka soo horjeeday oo tus in 3M uu "0% khalad leeyahay." Forbes ayaa sheegtay in 16-daqiiqo, 57-ilbiriqsi ay soo saartay warbixin qabyo ah oo leh 14 qaybood iyo magaca Autenrieth ee ugu sarreeya.

Sida laga soo xigtay Forbes, qabyo-qoraalka ayaa markii hore sheegay in 3M ay "0% mas'uul ka yihiin" qaraxa, laakiin luqaddaas ayaa markii dambe meesha laga saaray. Forbes waxa ay sheegtay in Autenrieth uu sidoo kale soo galiyay sawirka gaaska baadhista waxana uu waydiistay ChatGPT in uu garto waxa uu eegayo,waxa uu waydiiyay in dhinaca kale uu ka hor imanayo qoraalkiisa,waxana uu isticmaalay qaabka si uu dib ugu eego qabyada. Warbixintu waxay sheegtay in dhibcihii ugu dambeeyay ee ChatGPT uu siiyay mid ka mid ah qoraalladiisa 97 ka mid ah 100. Markii uu dhigay, Autenrieth wuxuu sheegay in AI ay ka caawisay inuu dhiso "nin caws ah," halka qareenka dacwoodayaasha uu sheegay in 85% ilaa 90% ee warbixinta 30-bog ka timid qaabka. Forbes ayaa ku warameysa in Autenrieth uusan ku raacsanayn qiyaastaas oo uu ku jawaabay, "Haddii aad sidaas tiraahdo."

Forbes waxa ay sheegtay in bishii Agoosto xeerbeegtida degmada Harris ay heleen Watson shiidida 70% masuul iyo 3M 30% ka masuul ah, taas oo $61.5 milyan siinaysa 24 degane iyo ganacsiyo ganacsi. Warbixintu waxa ay sheegtay in xukunku uu quseeyo kaliya dacwadaas, iyo in 3M ay qorsheynayaan inay racfaan ka qaataan. Forbes ayaa sidoo kale sheegtay in qareenka dacwoodayaashu ay heleen diiwaanka degdegga ah ee 365-bogga ah ee daahfurka oo ay u adeegsadeen inay su'aalo weydiiyaan Autenrieth kahor xeerbeegtida. Isha si madaxbanaan uma xaqiijiso dukumeentiyada, qoraalka tijaabada ama sharaxaada dhinacyada ee ka baxsan koontada Forbes iyo waxa ay u leedahay 404 Media.

Faahfaahinta isha: forbes.com ↗

Maxay muhiim u tahay

Kiisku waxa uu muujinayaa sida nidaamka AI u habayn karo caddaynta ku xeeran gebogebada uu bixiyo isticmaaleheeda, iyada oo sidoo kale muujinaysa sida dardargelinta, raritaanka iyo qoraalka la sameeyay ay qayb uga noqon karaan diiwaanka dacwadda. Forbes waxay soo warinaysaa in isla kalfadhiga ChatGPT lagu aqoonsaday "0% mas'uul" inay yihiin kuwo nugul markii la weydiisto inuu u dhaqmo sidii lataliye ka soo horjeeda. Dhacdadu waxay kor u qaadaysaa su'aalo wax ku ool ah oo loogu talagalay markhaatiyaasha khabiirka ah, qareennada iyo xirfadlayaasha kale ee isticmaalaya AI wax-soo-saarka shaqada sare leh.

Arrinta udub-dhexaadku maahan in khabiirku isticmaalo chatbot, laakiin in socodka shaqada ee la soo sheegay uu ku bilaabmay gunaanadkii la rabay. Forbes ayaa sheegtay in Autenrieth uu waydiistay ChatGPT si uu u muujiyo in 3M aysan lahayn khalad eber ka hor inta aan falanqaynta loo soo bandhigin fikradda khabiir. Tixdaasi waxay dhiirigelin kartaa nidaamka in la doorto, la soo koobo ama loo habeeyo shay siyaalo taageeraya booska la bixiyay. Waxa kale oo ay ka dhigaysaa habka shaqada ee khabiirka mid khuseeya: soojeedintu waxay muujin kartaa haddii falanqayntu ay ku bilaabatay caddayn ama u doodid.

Forbes waxa ay sheegtay in ChatGPT uu aqoonsaday daciifnimada ka dib markii lagu faray in uu u dhaqmo sidii lataliye ka soo horjeeda. Habkaas, qaabka ayaa lagu soo waramayaa in uu sheegay in "0% mas'uulka ka ah" uu ahaa bartilmaameed sahlan, in khabiirku uusan u ekaan u doodaha meeleynaya khalad sharci, iyo in boqolkiiba eber uu ahaa gabagabada qoondaynta xeerbeegtida halkii uu ka ahaan lahaa gabagabada injineernimada. Farqigani waxa uu soo jeedinayaa in wax-soo-saarka moodeelku uu si weyn ugu tiirsanaan karo qaabaynta hawsha. Ma caddaynayso in moodalku si madax-bannaan u ansixiyay labada dhinac, ishana ma bixinayso wax caddayn ah in diidmada tusaaluhu ay ahaayeen kuwo dhammaystiran ama la isku halayn karo.

Dhacdadani waxay leedahay saamayn balaadhan oo ku saabsan la xisaabtanka xirfadeed. Forbes waxay soo xiganeysaa cilmi-baarista Anthropic ee cilmi-nafsiga, iyadoo sharraxaysa u janjeera tababbarka jawaab-celinta bini'aadamka si loogu abaalmariyo jawaabaha ku heshiiya isticmaaleyaasha, waxayna soo xiganeysaa daraasad Saynis ah oo ku saabsan moodooyinka 11 AI oo lagu ogaaday in nidaamyada ay xaqiijiyeen ficillada isticmaaleyaasha 49% in ka badan inta dadku sameeyeen celcelis ahaan. Forbes waxay leedahay jawaabaha sasabanaya waxay kordhiyeen kalsoonida isticmaaleyaasha iyo kalsoonida moodeelka. Isha ma caddaynayso in natiijooyinkani ay si toos ah u sharxayaan habdhaqanka ChatGPT ee kiiskan, laakiin waxay u soo bandhigaysaa iyaga inay yihiin macnaha ku habboon sababta xaqiijinta raadinta ay khatar ugu noqon karto sharciga, injineernimada iyo shaqada kale ee natiijada sare leh.

Interactive Mechanism

Farsamaynta Is-dhexgalka: Sida Dhabta Ay U Shaqeyso

U baadh tignoolajiyada hoose ee ka dambeeya horumarkan si isdhexgal leh.

Thinking Budget (Test-Time Tokens):1,024 tokens
Complex Accuracy79%Math & Code Logic
Latency3.2sTime to first full output
Inference Cost$0.0092Per query estimated
Reasoning StyleStep VerificationInternal chain depth
Active Thinking Trace:
1Deconstruct user problem into formal constraints
2Propose candidate hypotheses & step-by-step calculation
3Self-correction: Backtrack and refute subtle edge cases
4Exhaustive consistency check & final output synthesis
Core takeaway: Test-time compute fundamentally changes AI economics. Instead of only scaling during pre-training, giving reasoning models more tokens at inference time allows them to systematically solve PhD-level STEM problems.
Hubinta Fikradda Is-dhexgalka+10 Points
AI Ethics Quiz

Why can ethical evaluation not be reduced to one model score?

Maxaa la daawan doona xiga

Daawo bal in racfaanku uu wax ka bedelo xukunka ama uu soo saaro xukuno dheeraad ah oo ku saabsan shaqada khabiirka ee ay caawiso AI. Xirfadlayaashu waa inay sidoo kale daawadaan sida maxkamadaha, la-talinta iyo shuruudaha ka-qaybgalku ay wax uga qabtaan sirta, ilaalinta, siidaynta iyo ogaanshaha soo-jeedinta iyo natiijooyinka. Isha ma cadeeyneyso in ChatGPT ay si maadi ah u saameysay go'aanka xeerbeegtida, in diiwaanka degdega ah uu ahaa mid dhameystiran, ama haddii ay maxkamadi heshay xadgudub gaar ah oo sharciyada xirfadda.

Su'aasha degdega ah ayaa ah maxaa dhacaya racfaanka. Forbes waxa ay sheegtay in 3M ay ku raacsanayn xukunka Degmada Harris oo ay qorshaynayso in ay racfaan ka qaadato, laakiin isha ma bixinayso racfaan, xukun ama jadwal. Dacwado dheeraad ah ayaa caddayn kara sida xukunka loola dhaqmay iyo haddii isticmaalka khabiirka ee ChatGPT uu noqdo arrin rasmi ah. Isha ma sheegan in xeerbeegtida ay ku tiirsanaayeen soo jeedinta, in maxkamaddu ay xukuntay Autenrieth, ama in xukunku uu ku salaysnaa isticmaalka AI.

Maxkamadaha iyo qareenada ayaa laga yaabaa inay wajahaan su'aalo joogto ah oo ku saabsan maaraynta walxaha AI la xiriira ee daahfurka. Forbes waxay leedahay diiwaanka degdega ah ayaa la soo saaray oo loo adeegsaday tijaabada, waxayna kula talisaa xirfadlayaasha inay shaqeeyaan sidii kicinta, dhejinta, soo saarista iyo xogta badan ee la raadin karo. Waxyaabaha aan la garanayn ee macnaha leh waxaa ka mid ah in dhammaan diiwaanada khuseeya la xafiday, waxa oggolaanshaha lagu maamulayo raritaanka faylalka qarsoodiga ah, iyo sida amarrada ilaalinta, shuruudaha ka qaybgalka ama xeerarka maxkamadda loo dabaqay. Isha ma bixinayso jawaabaha su'aalahaas.

Heerarka la taaban karo ee ay soo jeedisay Forbes waa in la sameeyo ra'yiga khabiirka dukumeentiyada, xogta, goobta, qalabka iyo heerarka maamulka ka hor inta aan la isticmaalin nooc; ka dib isticmaal AI si aad u soo koobto, u hubiso xisaabinta, u hagaajiso qorista luqadda cad ama ka doodida sababaynta. Xaqiiqo kasta oo la soo celiyo, xigasho, xisaabin iyo xigasho waxay weli u baahan doontaa hubinta diiwaanka asalka ah, halka fikradaha farsamo ay ka duwan yihiin gabagabada sharciga ah. Haddii dhaqamadan ay noqdaan shuruudo rasmi ah lama garanayo, sidoo kale sida ballaaran ee la midka ah warbixinnada ay taageerto AI ayaa horeyba ugu jiray kiisaska firfircoon.

Tilmaamaha la xidhiidha & su'aalaha

Anshaxa AIChatGPT iyo LLMsPrompt EngineeringWaa maxay AI?Tijaabi waxaad taqaan - isku day kedis AI oo bilaash ahKa raadi erey AI qaamuuskeenaRaac raadraaca maalgelinta AI
Tan faa'iido ma u heshay?