DalšíDalší průvodce
Citace falešných případů AI a soudní sankce: Mata v. Avianca
Společnost
PRŮVODCE společností
Lawyers have been sanctioned for filing briefs containing case citations that generative AI tools invented, most famously in Mata v.
Poslechněte si tento návodAI-vyprávěný · ~3 min
Avianca in 2023, where a federal judge imposed a $5,000 penalty on two attorneys and their firm. These cases matter because the failure is skipped verification, not use of the tool, and courts treat unchecked citations as a breach of the lawyer's duty to the court.
Mata v. Avianca, Inc. was an ordinary personal injury suit in the Southern District of New York: a passenger said a metal serving cart struck his knee on a 2019 flight. When Avianca moved to dismiss, the plaintiff's opposition cited decisions, including one styled Varghese v. China Southern Airlines, that did not exist. Neither opposing counsel nor the court could find them. The lawyer who did the research, Steven Schwartz, had used ChatGPT, believed it worked like a search engine, and asked it to confirm the cases were real, which it did. His colleague Peter LoDuca signed the filings. When the court ordered them to produce the decisions, they submitted AI-generated text presented as opinions. On June 22, 2023, Judge P. Kevin Castel imposed a $5,000 penalty on the two lawyers and their firm under Rule 11 and ordered them to write to their client and to each real judge falsely named as an author. The court made clear that using AI was not the problem. The lawyers failed by abandoning their responsibilities and continuing to stand by the fake cases after they were questioned. Later cases show the pattern persisting. The Second Circuit in Park v. Kim (2024) referred an attorney for possible discipline. In United States v. Cohen, Bard-generated citations reached a filing, though the judge declined sanctions. In Wadsworth v. Walmart (2025), lawyers were sanctioned over citations from their firm's in-house AI tool, showing that internal or legal-specific tools are not immune. Some judges, including Judge Brantley Starr of the Northern District of Texas in 2023, now require certifications about AI use. The central misconception is that asking the AI to double-check itself counts as verification. It does not. A model asked whether a case exists will often generate a confident yes. Verification means retrieving the actual opinion from an authoritative source and reading it.
In Mata v. Avianca, an attorney used ChatGPT to research an airline injury case, then asked ChatGPT whether the cases were real; it said they were, and the fabricated authorities were filed with the court.
In Park v. Kim (2024), the Second Circuit referred a lawyer to its grievance panel after a reply brief cited a nonexistent decision that she acknowledged had come from ChatGPT.
In United States v. Cohen, citations that Michael Cohen found using Google Bard and passed to his lawyer ended up in a court filing; Judge Jesse Furman declined to impose sanctions but found the citations had not been checked.
In Wadsworth v. Walmart (2025), a federal court in Wyoming sanctioned attorneys after motions cited cases produced by their firm's internal AI tool, with the heaviest penalty on the lawyer who drafted the filing.
Courts continue to encounter AI-fabricated citations, from experienced lawyers at large firms as well as from self-represented litigants, so the problem is not fading on its own. Responses vary: some judges issue standing orders requiring disclosure or certification, others rely on existing Rule 11 duties, and bar regulators increasingly treat repeated or concealed failures as disciplinary matters. Citation-checking features in research and drafting platforms may catch more errors before filing, but confirming that a case exists is easier than confirming it supports the stated proposition. The durable fix remains a firm-wide habit: every authority is read before it is cited.
Newsletter zdarma
Tři ověřené příběhy ze světa AI každý všední den ráno, psané srozumitelnou angličtinou. Navždy zdarma, bez reklam.
Jeden e-mail každý všední den. Odhlásit se můžete jedním kliknutím. Vaši adresu nikdy neprodáváme ani nesdílíme.
Otestujte se
Okamžitá zpětná vazba ke každé odpovědi a sdílitelný certifikát s ověřitelným ID po absolvování kurzu.
Podpořte bezplatnou AI vzdělávání. AI Understanding je nezisková organizace 501(c)(3) — žádné reklamy, žádná platba za přístup, nikdy. Darujte
Lawyers have been sanctioned for filing briefs containing case citations that generative AI tools invented, most famously in Mata v. Avianca in 2023, where a federal judge imposed a $5,000 penalty on two attorneys and their firm. These cases matter because the failure is skipped verification, not use of the tool, and courts treat unchecked citations as a breach of the lawyer's duty to the court.
ChatGPT potvrdil, že vynalezené případy byly skutečné, což ilustruje, proč požádat model o ověření vlastního výstupu není ověřením.
Soud uložil pokutu 5 000 dolarů podle pravidla 11 a požadoval, aby právníci informovali svého klienta a každého soudce, který byl nepravdivě označen za autora falešného posudku.
Soud uvedl, že samotné použití AI nebyl problém. Selhání bylo neověřování a následné hájení vykonstruovaných úřadů.
Citace pocházejí z vlastní platformy umělé inteligence firmy, což ukazuje, že interní nebo právní nástroje nezbavují potřebu ověřování.
Předvídatelná struktura názvů stran, reportéra, svazku, stránky, soudu a roku umožňuje modelu generovat věrohodně vypadající řetězce bez jakékoli vazby na skutečný názor.
Učte se dál
Pro toto téma bylo vybráno více průvodců
DalšíDalší průvodce
Citace falešných případů AI a soudní sankce: Mata v. Avianca
Společnost