Gids voor de samenleving

Wie is aansprakelijk als AI schade veroorzaakt?

When AI causes harm, liability usually falls on people and companies rather than on the AI.

Luister naar deze gidsAI-verteld · ~3 min

Op deze pagina4 minuten lezen
  1. Overzicht
  2. Diepe duik
  3. Implementatie in de echte wereld
  4. The Future of Who Is Liable When AI Causes Harm?
  5. Het in de praktijk brengen
  6. Blijf verkennen
  7. Veelgestelde vragen

Overzicht

That can be the business that deployed it, the developer or manufacturer of a defective product, or a professional who relied on it carelessly, and the claim is usually brought under existing law such as negligence, misrepresentation and product liability. It matters because courts and lawmakers are now deciding how these old rules apply to software that learns and changes. In the EU, product liability rules have been rewritten to cover software, including AI.

Diepe duik

Most AI harm claims fit into three familiar legal routes. Negligence asks whether someone failed to take reasonable care, for example by deploying a system without adequate testing or monitoring. Misrepresentation covers false statements a business makes, including statements made through its chatbot. Product liability can hold manufacturers strictly liable for defective products, meaning the injured person does not have to prove fault, only the defect, the damage and the causal link. The Air Canada case shows the simplest principle. In February 2024, the Civil Resolution Tribunal found the airline liable for negligent misrepresentation after its chatbot wrongly said bereavement fares could be claimed retroactively. The award was small, roughly C$800 including interest and fees, but the reasoning is clear: a company is responsible for all the information on its website, whether it comes from a static page or a chatbot. In the EU, the revised Product Liability Directive (EU) 2024/2853 entered into force in December 2024 and applies to products placed on the market from December 2026. It explicitly treats software, including AI systems, as a product. Free and open-source software developed outside commercial activity is excluded. Covered damage now includes medically recognized psychological harm and the destruction or corruption of data not used for professional purposes. Courts can order the disclosure of evidence and presume defect or causation where technical complexity makes proof excessively difficult. The separate AI Liability Directive, proposed in 2022 to ease fault-based claims, was dropped after the Commission announced in February 2025 that it expected no agreement. A common misconception is that AI creates a legal vacuum. In practice, existing doctrines are applied, although proving causation for opaque systems remains hard.

Implementatie in de echte wereld

In Moffatt v. Air Canada (2024), a British Columbia tribunal held the airline responsible after its website chatbot gave wrong information about bereavement fares. It rejected the argument that the chatbot was responsible for its own statements.

In Mata v. Avianca (2023), lawyers in New York were sanctioned for filing a brief with fake case citations produced by ChatGPT. The court held the professionals responsible for checking their filings.

Under the revised EU Product Liability Directive, a person injured by a defective AI-enabled medical device or robot can claim compensation from the manufacturer without proving fault.

In Garcia v. Character Technologies, a family alleged that a chatbot's design contributed to a teenager's death. In 2025 a US federal judge let product liability claims proceed past an early motion to dismiss, testing whether chatbot apps can be treated as products.

The Future of Who Is Liable When AI Causes Harm?

Expect more litigation that tests whether generative AI outputs count as products, how much protection the US Section 230 gives AI-generated content, and how courts handle causation for opaque systems. In the EU, the revised Product Liability Directive will start applying to new products from late 2026, and national courts will begin interpreting its presumptions. The withdrawn AI Liability Directive leaves fault-based claims to national law for now, so results may vary between countries. For organizations, careful documentation and human oversight are likely to matter more than any single new law.

Het in de praktijk brengen

Waarom het ertoe doet

  • Risico en veiligheid. Catastrofale en alledaagse schade door AI hangt af van wie de risico's begrijpt en wie kan handelen.
  • Duidelijkere beslissingen. Publieke en professionele geletterdheid bepalen of een krachtig veiligheidsbeleid politiek mogelijk is.
  • Door de hype heen snijden. Duidelijke verklaringen verminderen de kans op hypes, laboratorium-PR en vaag ethisch theater.

Pas op voor

  • Existentieel risico behandelen als sciencefiction, terwijl capaciteiten zich vermenigvuldigen.
  • De veiligheid van oppervlakteproducten verwarren met uitlijning onder hoge autonomie.
  • Hierdoor blijven niet-Engelstalige en niet-deskundige doelgroepen alleen bronnen van lage kwaliteit over.

Volgende stappen

  1. Afzonderlijke risico's voor productschade, misbruik en verlies van controle/verkeerde uitlijning.
  2. Vraag welk bewijs uw kijk op tijdlijnen en ernst zou veranderen.
  3. Geef de voorkeur aan primaire bronnen en concrete evaluaties boven marketingclaims.
  4. Identificeer één actiepad: carrière, beleid, financiering of vaardigheden – niet alleen bewustwording.

Blijf verkennen

Gratis nieuwsbrief

Ontvang de dagelijkse AI-briefing

Drie verifieerde AI-verhalen elke weekdagmorgen, geschreven in eenvoudig Engels. Gratis voor altijd, geen advertenties.

Eén e-mail elke weekdag. Afmelden met één klik. We verkopen of delen je adres nooit.

Test jezelf

Take the Who Is Liable When AI Causes Harm? quiz

Directe feedback op elke antwoord, en een deelbare certificaat met een verifieerbare ID zodra je een cursus hebt afgerond.

Quiz starten

Ondersteun gratis AI-onderwijs. AI Understanding is een 501(c)(3) non-profit — geen advertenties, geen betaalmuur, nooit. Doe een donatie

Veelgestelde vragen

Wie is aansprakelijk als AI schade veroorzaakt?

When AI causes harm, liability usually falls on people and companies rather than on the AI. That can be the business that deployed it, the developer or manufacturer of a defective product, or a professional who relied on it carelessly, and the claim is usually brought under existing law such as negligence, misrepresentation and product liability. It matters because courts and lawmakers are now deciding how these old rules apply to software that learns and changes. In the EU, product liability rules have been rewritten to cover software, including AI.

What did the tribunal decide in Moffatt v. Air Canada?

The tribunal found negligent misrepresentation and held that a company is responsible for all information on its website, including chatbot answers.

What does strict product liability mean?

Strict liability removes the need to prove carelessness, which makes it easier for injured people to recover compensation.

How does the revised EU Product Liability Directive treat software?

Directive (EU) 2024/2853 brings software within product liability. Free and open-source software developed outside commercial activity is excluded.

What happened to the proposed EU AI Liability Directive?

The Commission abandoned the proposal, which leaves fault-based AI claims to national laws for now.

Which new type of damage does the revised EU directive cover?

Covered damage now includes loss or corruption of data not used for professional purposes, as well as medically recognized psychological harm.