Guide-linked quiz · Medium Level
Fake AI Case Citations and Court Sanctions: Mata v. Avianca Quiz
Tests Mata’s actual sanctions, what the order did not prohibit, Rule 11 responsibility, and a reliable workflow for checking AI-assisted citations.
Question 1 of 8
What conduct led to sanctions in Mata v. Avianca?
Preview every question8 questions
Answers and explanations appear as you take the quiz.
- What conduct led to sanctions in Mata v. Avianca?
- Counsel cited nonexistent opinions but promptly withdrew them before the court questioned their authenticity
- Counsel filed nonexistent cases and false quotations produced with ChatGPT and did not promptly correct them
- Counsel cited authentic opinions with inaccurate pin cites and corrected them when challenged
- Counsel submitted unverified case summaries but withdrew them before relying on them
- What did the June 2023 order impose?
- A $5,000 joint-and-several penalty and specified notice letters to the client and falsely identified judges
- A $5,000 penalty imposed only on the law firm, with no notice letters
- Letters to the client and judges but no monetary penalty
- A continuing-education requirement in place of a penalty and notice letters
- What did the court say about AI assistance in legal work?
- AI use is improper in every legal research setting
- Using a reliable AI tool is not inherently improper, but attorneys must verify filings
- A citation need not be checked if it is provided by a commercial model
- Only the attorney who signs a filing has a duty to verify its authorities
- An AI-generated citation appears in a draft. What should the filing team check first?
- That the case exists and the full opinion supports the cited proposition
- That the reporter citation is syntactically valid, without opening the opinion
- That two model-generated citation lists contain the same case name
- That a headnote uses wording similar to the draft proposition
- Why does a headnote not independently verify a quoted passage from a judicial opinion?
- A headnote published with a case is part of the opinion and controls its wording
- A headnote may omit the exact quotation or procedural context in the opinion
- A case citation authenticates any quotation generated from the case without checking the passage
- A court adopts each publisher’s headnote as the official text of its opinion
- A real case addresses an unrelated procedural issue but is cited for a merits rule. What is the defect?
- The authority does not support the proposition for which it is cited
- The case is necessarily fake because it is not on point
- The citation is invalid unless the case comes from the same district
- A real case can only be cited when it is binding precedent
- What should a lawyer do after discovering a false citation in a filed submission?
- Promptly assess the scope and correct the record through the applicable procedure
- Wait to see whether the judge notices before taking action
- Replace the citation silently in a later copy without notifying anyone
- Add a disclaimer that AI may err while leaving the false citation in place
- In this case, what legal reach does the sanctions order have?
- The order held that using ChatGPT itself violated Rule 11 even if authorities were verified
- The order requires disclosure of AI assistance in every federal filing
- The order sanctions any citation mistake automatically without notice or an opportunity to respond
- It applied Rule 11 and the court’s authority to the specific conduct and record before it
Keep testing yourself
More quizzes picked for your level.