Guide-linked quiz · Medium Level

The Impossibility Theorem of Fairness Quiz

Tests the three-score-criteria result, base-rate and prediction assumptions, definitions of calibration and error-rate balance, and limits of the theorem.

Question 1 of 8

Which three conditions are central to the Kleinberg–Mullainathan–Raghavan result?

Preview every question8 questions

Answers and explanations appear as you take the quiz.

  1. Which three conditions are central to the Kleinberg–Mullainathan–Raghavan result?
    • Accuracy, speed, and model size
    • Privacy, transparency, and consent
    • Calibration, balance for the positive class, and balance for the negative class
    • Precision, recall, and training time
  2. Under what common special case can the three conditions avoid the stated conflict?
    • Equal base rates across groups or perfect prediction
    • Different data formats
    • A larger training set alone
    • Any use of a human reviewer
  3. What does calibration within groups mean?
    • False-positive rates are identical
    • Every group receives the same number of positive decisions
    • No protected attribute is used
    • People with a given score have the corresponding observed outcome frequency within each group
  4. For a thresholded classifier, which rates does Chouldechova’s related error-rate-balance criterion compare?
    • Positive decision rates only
    • False-positive and false-negative rates across groups
    • Training and inference time
    • Data retention and deletion rates
  5. What role do differing base rates play in the incompatibility results?
    • With differing outcome prevalence and imperfect predictions, some criteria cannot generally all hold exactly
    • They guarantee all fairness criteria can hold
    • They matter only for privacy laws
    • They mean the model is necessarily inaccurate
  6. Does the theorem prove that fairness is impossible in general?
    • Yes, every fair system is mathematically impossible
    • Yes, it proves discrimination is lawful
    • No; it concerns specified statistical criteria under specified assumptions
    • No, because it only concerns privacy
  7. Does the result choose which fairness metric a policy maker should prioritize?
    • Yes, it always mandates calibration
    • No; it shows a conflict but leaves the value judgment and harm trade-off to decision makers
    • Yes, it always mandates equal error rates
    • It makes all metrics irrelevant
  8. Why must an auditor check how the outcome label was produced?
    • Fairness metrics do not use outcomes
    • Labels determine whether code compiles
    • The model only works with image labels
    • The theorem assumes a defined target, but labels may be incomplete or reflect structural disadvantage

Keep testing yourself

More quizzes picked for your level.

View all quizzes