ΠΠ°Π»Π΅Π΅Π‘Π»Π΅Π΄ΡΡΡΠ΅Π΅ ΡΡΠΊΠΎΠ²ΠΎΠ΄ΡΡΠ²ΠΎ
ΠΠΎΠ΄Π΄Π΅Π»ΡΠ½ΡΠ΅ ΡΡΡΠ»ΠΊΠΈ Π½Π° Π΄Π΅Π»Π°, ΡΠΎΠ·Π΄Π°Π½Π½ΡΠ΅ ΠΠ, ΠΈ ΡΡΠ΄Π΅Π±Π½ΡΠ΅ ΡΠ°Π½ΠΊΡΠΈΠΈ: Π΄Π΅Π»ΠΎ Mata ΠΏΡΠΎΡΠΈΠ² Avianca
ΠΠ±ΡΠ΅ΡΡΠ²ΠΎ
Π Π£ΠΠΠΠΠΠ‘Π’ΠΠ ΠΠ ΠΠΠ©ΠΠ‘Π’ΠΠ£
The 2012 Da Silva Moore decision approved a negotiated predictive-coding protocol for one large electronic discovery matter.
ΠΡΠΎΡΠ»ΡΡΠ°ΠΉΡΠ΅ ΡΡΠΎ ΡΡΠΊΠΎΠ²ΠΎΠ΄ΡΡΠ²ΠΎΠΠ·Π²ΡΡΠ΅Π½ΠΎ ΠΠ Β· ~3 min
It did not endorse a vendor, require predictive coding in every case, or guarantee accuracy; it emphasized transparency, quality control, and context-specific review.
Predictive coding, also called technology-assisted review or computer-assisted review, uses human judgments about sample documents to train or guide software in prioritizing potentially relevant electronically stored information (ESI). In Da Silva Moore v. Publicis Groupe, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York considered a partiesβ negotiated ESI protocol in a large discovery matter. The February 2012 order allowed computer-assisted review under that protocol, with iterative review and transparency provisions. The decision was an early judicial approval in its factual setting, not a rule that predictive coding must be used or that a particular vendor or tool is endorsed. The court emphasized circumstances including the partiesβ agreement, large document volume, available alternatives, cost and proportionality, and the proposed processβs transparency. A later district-judge order affirmed the magistrate judgeβs discovery ruling under the applicable deferential review standard. Neither order declared the software infallible; the record recognized that no review method guarantees perfection. For modern discovery, counsel should agree on scope, responsiveness criteria, training and validation samples, privilege handling, production format, and quality control where appropriate. Monitor recall and precision as useful measures, but explain sampling limits and the consequences of errors. The case does not decide every future protocol or replace the Federal Rules, local rules, or case-specific judicial discretion. Treat it as an example of a court evaluating a transparent, negotiated protocol, not as blanket approval of any automated review process. In practice, the parties should clarify what counts as responsive before training, and specify how privileged material will be screened. Quality control can include a second-level review of selected nonresponsive documents and additional review when sampling reveals uncertainty. A negotiated protocol should explain who receives information about the process and how disputes are brought to the court.
Counsel proposes an ESI protocol and documents training and quality-control steps.
A discovery team discusses sampling and transparent reporting with opposing counsel.
A lawyer avoids citing Da Silva Moore as a universal mandate for predictive coding.
A court evaluates proportionality and the record in the case before it.
Courts continue to encounter different data volumes, tools, and party agreements. Predictive coding remains one option within technology-assisted review, with defensibility depending on the protocol and case record. Teams should document methods and adapt validation to the matter rather than relying on a single historical decision as a guarantee. Later cases may take different approaches because the data, parties, rules, and protocols differ. Counsel should use current rules and local precedent, consult on proportionality, and avoid presenting one district court order as a nationwide mandate. The enduring lesson is to make the method and quality controls explainable in the specific matter.
ΠΠ΅ΡΠΏΠ»Π°ΡΠ½Π°Ρ ΡΠ°ΡΡΡΠ»ΠΊΠ°
Π’ΡΠΈ ΠΏΡΠΎΠ²Π΅ΡΠ΅Π½Π½ΡΡ AI-ΠΈΡΡΠΎΡΠΈΠΈ ΠΊΠ°ΠΆΠ΄ΠΎΠ΅ ΡΡΡΠΎ Π±ΡΠ΄Π½Π΅Π³ΠΎ Π΄Π½Ρ, Π½Π°ΠΏΠΈΡΠ°Π½Π½ΡΠ΅ ΠΏΡΠΎΡΡΡΠΌ Π°Π½Π³Π»ΠΈΠΉΡΠΊΠΈΠΌ. ΠΠ΅ΡΠΏΠ»Π°ΡΠ½ΠΎ Π½Π°Π²ΡΠ΅Π³Π΄Π°, Π±Π΅Π· ΡΠ΅ΠΊΠ»Π°ΠΌΡ.
ΠΠ΄Π½ΠΎ ΡΠ»Π΅ΠΊΡΡΠΎΠ½Π½ΠΎΠ΅ ΠΏΠΈΡΡΠΌΠΎ ΠΊΠ°ΠΆΠ΄ΡΠΉ Π±ΡΠ΄Π½ΠΈΠΉ Π΄Π΅Π½Ρ. ΠΡΠΏΠΈΡΠ°ΡΡΡΡ Π² ΠΎΠ΄ΠΈΠ½ ΠΊΠ»ΠΈΠΊ. ΠΡ Π½ΠΈΠΊΠΎΠ³Π΄Π° Π½Π΅ ΠΏΡΠΎΠ΄Π°Π΅ΠΌ ΠΈ Π½Π΅ ΠΏΠ΅ΡΠ΅Π΄Π°Π΅ΠΌ Π²Π°Ρ Π°Π΄ΡΠ΅Ρ.
ΠΡΠΎΠ²Π΅ΡΡΡΠ΅ ΡΠ΅Π±Ρ
ΠΠ³Π½ΠΎΠ²Π΅Π½Π½Π°Ρ ΠΎΠ±ΡΠ°ΡΠ½Π°Ρ ΡΠ²ΡΠ·Ρ ΠΏΠΎ ΠΊΠ°ΠΆΠ΄ΠΎΠΌΡ ΠΎΡΠ²Π΅ΡΡ ΠΈ ΠΎΠ±ΡΠΈΠΉ ΡΠ΅ΡΡΠΈΡΠΈΠΊΠ°Ρ Ρ ΠΏΡΠΎΠ²Π΅ΡΡΠ΅ΠΌΡΠΌ ΠΈΠ΄Π΅Π½ΡΠΈΡΠΈΠΊΠ°ΡΠΎΡΠΎΠΌ ΠΏΠΎΡΠ»Π΅ ΠΏΡΠΎΡ ΠΎΠΆΠ΄Π΅Π½ΠΈΡ ΠΊΡΡΡΠ°.
ΠΠΎΠ΄Π΄Π΅ΡΠΆΠΈΡΠ΅ Π±Π΅ΡΠΏΠ»Π°ΡΠ½ΠΎΠ΅ ΠΎΠ±ΡΠ°Π·ΠΎΠ²Π°Π½ΠΈΠ΅ Π² ΠΎΠ±Π»Π°ΡΡΠΈ ΠΈΡΠΊΡΡΡΡΠ²Π΅Π½Π½ΠΎΠ³ΠΎ ΠΈΠ½ΡΠ΅Π»Π»Π΅ΠΊΡΠ°. AI Understanding β ΡΡΠΎ Π½Π΅ΠΊΠΎΠΌΠΌΠ΅ΡΡΠ΅ΡΠΊΠ°Ρ ΠΎΡΠ³Π°Π½ΠΈΠ·Π°ΡΠΈΡ 501(c)(3). ΠΠΈΠΊΠ°ΠΊΠΎΠΉ ΡΠ΅ΠΊΠ»Π°ΠΌΡ ΠΈ ΠΏΠ»Π°ΡΠ½ΠΎΠ³ΠΎ Π΄ΠΎΡΡΡΠΏΠ°. Π‘Π΄Π΅Π»Π°ΡΡ ΠΏΠΎΠΆΠ΅ΡΡΠ²ΠΎΠ²Π°Π½ΠΈΠ΅
The 2012 Da Silva Moore decision approved a negotiated predictive-coding protocol for one large electronic discovery matter. It did not endorse a vendor, require predictive coding in every case, or guarantee accuracy; it emphasized transparency, quality control, and context-specific review.
The opinion approved the case-specific protocol and explicitly did not mandate use in every case.
The court considered agreement, volume, alternatives, proportionality, and transparency.
The opinion cautions that this protocol is not automatically right for future cases.
The court considered transparent process and quality review, while recognizing no tool is perfect.
Predictive coding supports review of electronic documents; legal relevance criteria remain contextual.
ΠΡΠΎΠ΄ΠΎΠ»ΠΆΠ°ΠΉΡΠ΅ ΡΡΠΈΡΡΡΡ
ΠΡΡΠ³ΠΈΠ΅ ΡΡΠΊΠΎΠ²ΠΎΠ΄ΡΡΠ²Π°, Π²ΡΠ±ΡΠ°Π½Π½ΡΠ΅ ΠΏΠΎ ΡΡΠΎΠΉ ΡΠ΅ΠΌΠ΅
ΠΠ°Π»Π΅Π΅Π‘Π»Π΅Π΄ΡΡΡΠ΅Π΅ ΡΡΠΊΠΎΠ²ΠΎΠ΄ΡΡΠ²ΠΎ
ΠΠΎΠ΄Π΄Π΅Π»ΡΠ½ΡΠ΅ ΡΡΡΠ»ΠΊΠΈ Π½Π° Π΄Π΅Π»Π°, ΡΠΎΠ·Π΄Π°Π½Π½ΡΠ΅ ΠΠ, ΠΈ ΡΡΠ΄Π΅Π±Π½ΡΠ΅ ΡΠ°Π½ΠΊΡΠΈΠΈ: Π΄Π΅Π»ΠΎ Mata ΠΏΡΠΎΡΠΈΠ² Avianca
ΠΠ±ΡΠ΅ΡΡΠ²ΠΎ