Back to News
PolicyAI Understanding briefing

New book offers a standard for expert witnesses using AI and prompts courts to require AI prompt records

Bill Hartzer’s book, *The Expert Record*, proposes an eight‑clause standard for expert witnesses who rely on artificial intelligence and details how attorneys can vet AI use, as courts begin ordering production of AI prompts.

4 min readRead the linked source
Source-page capture accompanying New book offers a standard for expert witnesses using AI and prompts courts to require AI prompt records
Source referenceSource recorded
Publisher
natlawreview.com
Source type
Linked source — primary-source status has not been established.
ContextUnderstand this in 60 seconds

Key terms

Prompt
The input instructions and context provided to a generative model.
Artificial Intelligence (AI)
The broad field of building systems that perform tasks requiring pattern recognition, reasoning, language, or decision-making.
Weight
A learned numeric value that scales signals passing through a neural network.
Test yourselfAI Ethics Quiz

What happened

Hartzer Press released *The Expert Record: The Standard for Expert Witnesses Using AI*, a book that outlines an eight‑clause professional standard for expert witnesses who incorporate AI into their analyses. The book provides a checklist for attorneys to assess an expert’s AI inputs and outputs before engagement, and it advises experts on how to document prompts, maintain reproducibility, and disclose AI use. A companion website, theexpertrecord.com, publishes the full standard and maintains a continuously updated docket of court cases where AI use has been litigated or ordered disclosed. The release notes recent judicial activity—such as a Connecticut magistrate’s order for AI prompts in *Conservation Law Foundation v. Shell Oil* and a California appellate decision in *Gillespie v. Superior Court*—that signal AI records are becoming a discovery issue. The book is available in paperback, hardcover, and ebook formats through major retailers, and media review copies can be requested.

Hartzer Press announced the publication of *The Expert Record: The Standard for Expert Witnesses Using AI* by Bill Hartzer, a veteran expert witness with more than 25 years of experience in SEO, domain name disputes, and forensic internet investigations. The book defines an eight‑clause professional standard (Version 1.0) that experts can adopt, cite in reports, and be examined on. The clauses address the sequence of AI use, non‑delegation of judgment, independent authority, pre‑adoption checkability, reproducibility, custody and confidentiality, contemporaneous record‑keeping, and full disclosure.

The release highlights two recent cases that illustrate the emerging legal relevance of AI prompts: a Connecticut magistrate’s order in *Conservation Law Foundation v. Shell Oil Co.* requiring production of an expert’s AI prompts (currently stayed pending an objection), and a California appellate decision in *Gillespie v. Superior Court* where a forensic psychologist’s use of ChatGPT as a “thought partner” was scrutinized but ultimately upheld. These cases underscore that courts are beginning to treat AI logs as discoverable and potentially material to expert credibility.

A companion website, theexpertrecord.com, provides free, unregistered access to the full eight‑clause standard and maintains a “AI in the Courtroom” docket that logs ongoing litigation, regulatory, or rulemaking actions involving AI. Each docket entry records the party’s AI activity, the tribunal’s response, the current status, and the last verification date, offering a real‑time resource for practitioners.

The book is distributed in paperback, hardcover, and ebook formats through Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Bookshop.org, and other retailers, with links provided on the companion site. Review copies are available to media upon request, and Hartzer is offering interviews, podcast appearances, webinars, CLE programs, and guest lectures to discuss the standard and its practical application.

Source details: natlawreview.com

Why it matters

The book arrives as courts across the United States are beginning to treat AI logs as discoverable evidence, turning what was previously a technical detail into a legal liability. By codifying a standard that emphasizes reproducibility, non‑delegation, and a contemporaneous record, the guide aims to give attorneys a concrete framework for questioning expert testimony that relies on AI, potentially reducing disputes over the reliability of AI‑generated opinions. If widely adopted, the standard could influence how expert witnesses document their work, shape discovery practices, and inform future rulemaking or case law regarding AI transparency in litigation. It also signals to the broader legal community that AI integration is no longer a peripheral concern but a core component of evidentiary scrutiny.

The emergence of AI disclosure as a discovery issue marks a shift in evidentiary standards, moving from questioning the validity of AI‑generated conclusions to demanding a transparent audit trail of the inputs that produced those conclusions. This shift could increase litigation costs and procedural complexity for experts and their retainers.

By offering a concrete, eight‑clause framework, the book gives attorneys a ready‑made set of questions and documentation expectations, potentially streamlining pre‑engagement vetting and reducing the risk of surprise challenges during cross‑examination.

If courts begin to reference the standard in rulings, it could become de‑facto precedent, influencing how bar associations and professional certification bodies draft guidelines for AI‑enabled expert testimony.

The companion website’s docket creates a public, searchable record of AI‑related litigation trends, which could inform future policy debates and academic research on AI transparency in the legal system.

Interactive Mechanism

Interactive Mechanism: How It Actually Works

Explore the underlying technology behind this development interactively.

System Requirements:
Best ArchitecturePure RAGRecommended pattern
Hallucination RiskVery LowGrounding efficacy
Update Cost$0 (Vector sync)Ongoing maintenance
Core takeaway: Fine-tuning teaches models how to speak (form, style, syntax); RAG teaches models what to say (verifiable facts). Never use fine-tuning alone for factual memory.
Interactive Concept Check+10 Points
AI Ethics Quiz

Why can ethical evaluation not be reduced to one model score?

What to watch next

Future court rulings on the enforceability of the eight‑clause standard, adoption of the standard by professional bodies or bar associations, and any legislative proposals that codify AI disclosure requirements. Monitoring how law firms and expert networks incorporate the checklist into engagement letters and discovery protocols will indicate the standard’s practical impact.

Whether appellate or trial courts cite the eight‑clause standard in future opinions, thereby granting it judicial .

Adoption of the standard by bar associations, law schools, or expert witness certification programs, which would signal broader professional acceptance.

Legislative or regulatory initiatives at the state or federal level that codify AI disclosure requirements for expert testimony.

The evolution of discovery practices, such as the development of standardized request forms or court orders specifically targeting AI logs.

Related guides & quizzes

Found this useful?